Project Fortress, 3.8.19
By Alan W. Dowd
We’ve
all heard the wry, old adage that the Ark was built by amateurs, while
the Titanic was built by credentialed professionals. It’s a bit of an
exaggeration, to be sure, but it serves as a reminder that intelligence
and knowledge don’t always get the job done. Indeed, all of the
information, data and knowledge in the world is worthless—or downright
dangerous—if we don’t have the wisdom to make proper use of it. That’s
our challenge in this age of endless data and information overload.
“We are awash in data,” Director of National Intelligence Dan Coats observes.
“We have to understand how our adversaries use that data against our
interests, and how we can prevent that from happening, as well as use it
for our own purposes.” He adds that “It’s a constant struggle to process data, analyze it, and convert
it into knowledge and understanding for our customers [Congress and the
president]. It’s one of our greatest challenges.”
Similarly, AEI’s Jonah Goldberg laments how “We drown in information, but we starve for knowledge.”
What both Coats and Goldberg are saying is that information and data
do not equal knowledge. Knowledge is the process of organizing data and
information into something useable and then applying it to a problem:
growing crops, inventing the printing press, creating constitutional
government, building the internal combustion engine, developing a
vaccine, discovering the atom and then unlocking its power, exploring
the lunar surface, writing computer code.
The summit of knowledge is science. The word “science” literally
means “the state of knowing…knowledge as distinguished
from ignorance…systematized knowledge.”
Yet science isn’t the summit of human understanding. Just as we have
access to far more information and data than earlier generations, we
also have access to more knowledge and indeed more science than earlier
generations.
Before the 20th century, human knowledge doubled every hundred years. By the middle of the 20th century, it was
every 25 years. At the dawn of the 21st century, human knowledge was
doubling every 12 months. Today, this exponential growth of knowledge is
accelerating, which explains the growing number of sciences—many of
them spawned by new technologies capable of harvesting and manipulating
information.
What we lack amidst all this information and knowledge is wisdom.
“While science has increased man’s power in ways that former men never
dreamt of,” political philosopher Leo Strauss observed in the midst of
the terrifying new age of nuclear weapons, “it is absolutely incapable
of telling men how to use that power.”
That’s where wisdom comes into play; indeed, that’s where wisdom is
essential. To paraphrase Goldberg, today's world starves for wisdom.
Clues
Knowledge may be understood as a stairstep to wisdom. But knowledge alone does not make us wise.
To illustrate this point, let’s conduct a quick thought experiment:
Take a moment and think about the smartest person you know—the person
who was top in your graduating class, the person who has all the answers
at work, the person who has all those degrees on his wall or all those
letters next to her name testifying to all of his or her knowledge. Now,
think about the wisest person you know—the person you seek out for
counsel and advice when you have an important decision to make, when
you’re faced with a no-win dilemma.
The odds are high that you’re thinking of two different people, that
the smartest person you know is not the wisest person you know.
The point of this exercise is that wisdom is more than intelligence
and intellect, more than turning data and information into knowledge.
Wisdom is the art, the craft, the gift of sifting through knowledge,
mixing it with judgment and experience, and then applying it to life.
That’s an imprecise definition because wisdom, unlike knowledge, is
an imprecise quality. Wisdom cannot be honed into a science. Wisdom
cannot be defined by a formula. Wisdom cannot be obtained by a course of
study.
Yet we know it when we see it or hear it. As the Book of Daniel puts
it, “Those who are wise will shine like the brightness of the heavens.”
In other words, wise people tend to stand out.
The collection of timeless wisdom known as the Bible offers helpful
clues as to where to find such people and where to find wisdom.
The psalmist tells us that wisdom is found when we learn to value the preciousness and briefness of life, that “the fear of the Lord is
the beginning of wisdom.” Put another way, the ability—and the
humility—to recognize that there is something beyond us, something
bigger than us, something that calls us, something we must one day
answer to, is the primary ingredient of wisdom.
Proverbs explains that wise people “bring calm” and “healing.” They
also bring joy to their families and “turn away anger,” according to
Proverbs. “The one who is wise,” Proverbs explains, “saves lives.” In
fact, wisdom, like the dutiful soldier, protects us and watches over us.
Interestingly, Proverbs says that wise people are not know-it-alls. Instead, they are open to learning; they “store up knowledge,” welcome instruction and “listen to advice.” And according to Proverbs, if we follow their
example, if we spend time “walking with the wise,” if we “listen to
advice and accept discipline,” we can become wise—or at least wiser.
Many of these attributes of wisdom come with living life and growing
up, which is why we generally identify wisdom with gray hair and
wrinkled skin. But all of us know young people who are wise and old
people who are foolish. Indeed, in Job, we learn that the gift of wisdom
is not reserved for the old. As Job’s wise, young friend Elihu
explained, “It is not only the old who are wise, not only the aged who
understand what is right…It is the spirit in a person, the breath of the
Almighty, that gives them understanding.” Elihu’s observation further
underscores that wisdom, on some level, is a gift.
Ecclesiastes bluntly concludes that wisdom equals power and “is better than weapons of war.” This makes sense, for at its best
wisdom can help nations avoid war. But even when war proves unavoidable,
wisdom ensures that a nation or an army or an individual is prepared
for the chaos and calamity of war.
Storms
That brings us back, in a roundabout way, to what worries Director
Coats: Are industry and the intelligence community turning all that
information and data they possess into useable knowledge for
policymakers? More important yet, do policymakers in Congress and the
White House have the wisdom to make proper use of all that information
and knowledge?
These questions call to mind two ancient parables.
The first asks, “What
king would go to war against another king without first sitting down to
consider whether his 10,000 soldiers could go up against the 20,000
coming against him? And
if he didn’t think he could win, he would send a representative to
discuss terms of peace while his enemy was still a long way off."
The given of this parable is that threats and
conflicts are going arise in this broken world—and that wise leaders
find a way to deal with those threats. In this parable,
both kings are wise—one because he recognizes that he’s outnumbered; the
other because he makes sure that he’s not.
In a similar way, the parable of the two builders reminds us of the importance of preparedness and planning. The wise
builder built his house on the solid foundation of rock. The foolish
builder didn’t take the time or spend the money or devote the resources
to digging down to bedrock. Instead, he took the easy way and built his
house on sand. When the storms came, only the house built on rock
survived.
The given of this parable is that disaster tends to affect all of us
in this broken world—and that only those who are wise enough to prepare
and plan ahead will survive the storms.
Wise people—the wise leader, the wise advisor, the wise general, the
wise farmer, the wise builder, the wise shopkeeper, the wise homemaker,
the wise parent—apply their knowledge about the past, their
understanding of human nature, and their experience in the world to
prepare and plan for what lies ahead. They don’t know all the answers,
but they know how to work through the process of finding answers. As a
result, they “bring calm” and “save lives.”
These are the kinds of people we need in government today.